From: Presentation attack detection and biometric recognition in a challenge-response formalism
Authors | Ref | (P)opulation to (S)ingle Subject | (B)ehavioral to (P)hysiological | (A)utomated to (C)ontrolled | (O)vert to (C)overt | (U)npracticed to (P)racticed | Manuscript Type | (R)ecognition to (P)AD |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Simons et al. (2014) | [21] | P | B | A | C | U | Paper | P |
Jakobsson (2015) | [22] | P | B | C | O | P | Paper | Mix |
Frischholz and Werner (2003) | [8] | P | B | C | O | U | Paper | P |
Ganesh et al. (2017) | [23] | P | B | C | O | U | Paper | P |
De Marsico et al. (2012) | [24] | P | B | C | O | U | Paper | P |
Saad and Moustafa (2014) | [25] | P | B | C | O | U | Paper | P |
Shen et al. (2018) | [26] | P | B | C | O | U | Paper | P |
Ali et al. (2012) | [27] | P | B | C | O | U | Paper | P |
Li et al. (2016) | [28] | P | B | Mix | O | U | Paper | R |
Zhang et al. (2018) | [29] | S | B | A | C | U | Paper | R |
Gong et al. (2016) | [30] | S | B | C | C | P | Paper | Mix |
Tan et al. (2018) | [16] | S | P | A | C | U | Paper | Mix |
Martinovic et al. (2014) | [12] | S | P | C | C | U | Paper | R |
Sluganovic (2016) | [13] | S | B | A | O | U | Paper | R |
Bhardwaj (2017) | [31] | S | B | C | O | P | Paper | P |
Burgbacher et al. (2014) | [18] | S | B | C | O | P | Paper | R |
Ma et al. (2018) | [32] | S | B | C | O | P | Paper | R |
Skerpac (2002) | [20] | S | B | C | O | U | Paper | Mix |
Tian et al. (2017) | [33] | S | B | C | O | U | Paper | Mix |
Sae-Bae et al. (2012) | [34] | S | B | C | O | U | Paper | R |
Chauhan et al. (2017) | [35] | S | Mix | C | O | U | Paper | R |
Sae-Bae and Jakobsson (2014) | [36] | S | Mix | C | O | U | Paper | R |
Blanchard et al. (2019) | [15] | S | P | A | O | P | Paper | R |
Li et al. (2019) | [19] | S | P | A | O | U | Paper | Mix |
Yano et al. (2012) | [6] | S | P | A | O | U | Paper | P |
Gao et al. (2019) | [17] | S | P | A | O | U | Paper | R |
Bhaskaran (2011) | [37] | P | B | C | O | U | Patent | Mix |
Chaudhury (2014) | [38] | P | B | C | O | U | Patent | P |
Lindemann (2018) | [39] | P | Mix | A | O | U | Patent | P |
Roos (2014) | [40] | S | B | C | O | P | Patent | P |
Pearson and Contolini (2005) | [41] | S | B | C | O | U | Patent | Mix |
Roblek and Sharifi (2014) | [42] | S | B | C | O | U | Patent | Mix |
Skerpac (2014) | [43] | S | B | C | O | U | Patent | Mix |